Why taking responsibility, investigating incidents and learning from mistakes are essential to good care leadership.
In health and social care, things don't always go according to plan.
A resident may have a fall. A pharmacy might fail to deliver medication. A district nurse may not arrive for a scheduled visit, or a member of staff might make a mistake.
Even in well-managed care services, incidents can happen.
CQC doesn't expect a service where nothing ever goes wrong. However, it does expect providers to manage risks, respond appropriately, take responsibility and learn from incidents.
For Registered Managers and care providers, the important question isn't simply:
What went wrong?
It's also:
What did you do about it, and what have you changed to prevent it happening again?
1. CQC Wants to See Action, Not Just Policies
Every care service should have clear policies and procedures covering incident reporting, safeguarding, medication management, complaints, risk assessments and the duty of candour.
But having policies stored in a folder isn't enough.
Under CQC Regulation 17 – Good governance, providers must have effective systems to assess, monitor and improve the quality and safety of their services.
Registered Managers should be able to demonstrate:
- Staff understand the relevant policies and procedures.
- Incidents and concerns are reported promptly.
- Immediate action is taken to protect people from harm.
- Appropriate investigations are carried out.
- Risks are reviewed and managed.
- Lessons are shared with staff.
- Improvements are monitored to ensure they are effective.
A policy is only effective when it is understood, followed and reflected in everyday practice.
2. What Happens When the Pharmacy Doesn't Deliver Medication?
Imagine a care home orders medication for a resident, but the pharmacy fails to deliver it on time.
The Registered Manager explains:
"We ordered the medication on time. We did everything we were supposed to do. It was the pharmacy that didn't deliver."
That may be true.
However, explaining who caused the problem doesn't demonstrate how the service responded.
CQC may want to understand:
- When did staff realise the medication hadn't arrived?
- Was the risk to the resident assessed?
- Did anyone contact the pharmacy and escalate the delay?
- Was appropriate clinical advice sought?
- Were safe alternative arrangements considered?
- Was the resident monitored where necessary?
- Was the incident recorded and investigated?
- What action was taken to prevent the situation happening again?
The pharmacy may have caused the initial problem, but the care provider still has responsibilities for managing the risks to the person receiving care.
Under CQC Regulation 12 – Safe care and treatment, providers must assess and manage risks to people's health and safety, including risks associated with medicines.
The important question is not just who was responsible for the delay, but how the service protected the resident.
3. What If a District Nurse Doesn't Turn Up?
Care providers regularly work alongside district nurses, GPs, community healthcare teams and other external professionals.
But what happens when someone doesn't attend a scheduled appointment?
Imagine a resident requires treatment from a district nurse, but the nurse doesn't arrive.
The manager explains:
"The nurse didn't turn up. We contacted the nursing team, so there was nothing else we could do."
CQC may want to know whether the response was appropriate to the person's needs and the level of risk.
For example:
- Did staff recognise the potential impact of the missed visit?
- Was the nursing team contacted and the concern escalated?
- Was alternative clinical advice sought where necessary?
- Was the resident monitored?
- Were the person's care records updated?
- Were appropriate follow-up arrangements made?
- Was the incident reviewed if it exposed a wider risk?
Simply stating that an external professional failed to attend isn't enough if the person remained at risk.
CQC's Safe systems, pathways and transitions quality statement highlights the importance of safe care arrangements and effective working between services.
External professionals have their own responsibilities, but care providers must still take appropriate action within their role to protect the people they support.
4. What If a Resident Has a Fall?
Falls can happen in care settings, even where risk assessments and preventative measures are in place.
A fall doesn't automatically mean that a provider has failed to deliver safe care.
However, the response matters.
A Registered Manager should be able to demonstrate that:
- The resident received an appropriate immediate assessment.
- Medical assistance was obtained where necessary.
- The incident was accurately documented.
- Relevant people and organisations were informed where required.
- The resident's risk assessment and care plan were reviewed.
- Environmental, equipment or staffing factors were considered.
- Appropriate preventative measures were implemented.
For example, if a resident repeatedly falls when getting out of bed, simply recording each fall without reviewing the underlying risks may indicate that the service isn't learning.
CQC's Learning culture quality statement emphasises the importance of learning from incidents and using that learning to improve safety.
The aim isn't to promise that nobody will ever fall. It's to demonstrate that risks are assessed, incidents are managed and reasonable steps are taken to prevent avoidable harm.
5. What If Your Own Staff Make a Mistake?
This is where effective leadership becomes particularly important.
Imagine a care worker administers medication incorrectly, fails to follow a care plan or misses an important change in someone's condition.
A manager shouldn't automatically blame the individual or attempt to minimise what happened.
Instead, the service needs to investigate the circumstances.
Consider:
- Was the member of staff appropriately trained?
- Were they competent to carry out the task?
- Were instructions clear?
- Was appropriate supervision available?
- Were staffing pressures a contributing factor?
- Did the service have suitable systems and procedures?
- Had similar concerns been raised previously?
Sometimes an individual makes a mistake. Sometimes the investigation reveals wider problems with training, communication or management systems.
Often, several factors contribute.
The investigation should be fair, proportionate and focused on protecting people, establishing what happened and preventing recurrence.
Where the service has made a mistake, managers should acknowledge it and take appropriate responsibility.
That may involve additional training, changes to procedures, closer supervision, disciplinary action where justified or improvements to the service's systems.
Taking responsibility isn't a weakness. It's an essential part of good leadership.
6. CQC Doesn't Want Excuses. It Wants Evidence.
When something goes wrong, saying "we dealt with it" isn't the same as demonstrating what happened.
Registered Managers should maintain appropriate records showing how incidents were managed.
Examples of evidence include:
Incident reports
A factual account of what happened, when it occurred, who was affected and the immediate response.
Investigation records
Evidence of how the incident was examined, including findings and contributing factors.
Risk assessments and care plan reviews
Documentation showing that risks were reconsidered and care arrangements updated where necessary.
Communication records
Evidence of appropriate contact with families, healthcare professionals, safeguarding teams or other relevant organisations.
Corrective action plans
A record of what needs to change, who is responsible and when the action should be completed.
Staff training and supervision
Evidence that lessons were shared and staff received additional support where needed.
Audits and follow-up checks
Records demonstrating whether the improvements were implemented and whether they worked.
Under Regulation 17 – Good governance, providers must maintain appropriate systems and records to support safe, effective management.
Recording an incident is the beginning of the process, not the end.
7. Understanding the Duty of Candour
Being open and honest when something goes wrong is a fundamental part of delivering safe and compassionate care.
Under CQC Regulation 20 – Duty of candour, registered providers must act openly and transparently with people receiving care and treatment.
Certain notifiable safety incidents trigger additional legal requirements, including:
- Informing the relevant person about the incident.
- Providing an appropriate explanation.
- Offering an apology.
- Providing reasonable support.
- Following the required written notification and record-keeping procedures.
Not every incident meets the legal threshold for a notifiable safety incident. Nevertheless, honesty and transparency should be part of everyday care practice.
An apology should not be avoided simply because an investigation is still ongoing.
CQC's guidance also makes clear that apologising does not, in itself, amount to admitting legal liability.
A culture of openness builds trust. A culture of hiding mistakes creates further risks.
8. Learning From Incidents Is What Makes a Service Well-led
A well-led care service isn't one where staff are afraid to report mistakes.
It's one where concerns are taken seriously, incidents are investigated and improvements are made.
CQC's Learning culture quality statement focuses on an environment where people can raise concerns and where incidents are used as opportunities for learning.
Registered Managers should encourage staff to speak up while maintaining appropriate accountability for unsafe practice.
Managers should also look for patterns.
For example:
Repeated medication errors
Is there a problem with training, medication administration procedures or staffing arrangements?
Increasing numbers of falls
Do risk assessments, equipment or care plans need reviewing?
Missed visits from external healthcare professionals
Are communication and escalation procedures effective?
Repeated complaints from families
Is there an underlying issue with communication, staffing or the quality of care?
Addressing individual incidents is important, but identifying wider patterns can help prevent future problems.
Good leadership means learning from what went wrong and checking that the changes made a difference.
9. Five Questions Every Registered Manager Should Ask After an Incident
When something goes wrong in your service, ask yourself:
1. What happened?
Establish the facts and ensure the incident is recorded accurately.
2. What did we do immediately?
Demonstrate how the person was protected, supported and given appropriate care.
3. Why did it happen?
Investigate the circumstances and identify any contributing factors.
4. What have we changed?
Record the actions taken, including changes to procedures, training or risk management.
5. How do we know the changes worked?
Review the outcome, monitor for recurring problems and retain evidence of improvement.
These five questions provide a practical starting point for reviewing incidents and demonstrating accountability.
They do not replace statutory notification requirements, safeguarding duties or other applicable legal obligations.
10. What If CQC Visits Tomorrow?
Imagine an inspector asks:
"Can you tell me about an incident that happened in your service and what you learned from it?"
A confident Registered Manager should be able to explain the incident, describe the immediate response, discuss the investigation and show what improvements followed.
For example:
"We identified a delay in a resident receiving medication. We contacted the pharmacy, obtained appropriate clinical advice and took action to manage the risk. We then reviewed our medication ordering and escalation procedures, briefed staff on the changes and carried out follow-up checks."
This response demonstrates more than simply identifying the cause.
It shows that the service recognised the problem, responded appropriately and reviewed its systems.
CQC's assessment approach considers evidence from different sources, including people's experiences, staff feedback, observations and processes.
Managers should therefore be able to demonstrate that their actions have translated into safer, more effective care.
Final Thoughts: Good Care Leadership Isn't About Being Perfect
In health and social care, things can go wrong.
A pharmacy may fail to deliver medication. A visiting nurse may miss an appointment. A resident may have a fall, or a member of staff may make a mistake.
CQC does not automatically treat every incident as evidence of poor care.
However, serious failures to prevent avoidable harm, manage risks, respond appropriately or meet regulatory duties can result in enforcement action.
The important distinction is how a provider manages its responsibilities before, during and after an incident.
Blaming an external organisation doesn't remove your responsibility to respond appropriately.
Having policies in place doesn't mean they're being followed.
And recording an incident doesn't prove that the service has learned from it.
Strong leadership means recognising problems, taking responsibility where appropriate, protecting people and demonstrating continuous improvement.
For every Registered Manager, the message is simple:
Don't just explain what went wrong. Be ready to show what you did about it.
Developing Leadership and Management Skills in Adult Social Care
At KIB Healthcare Training, we support care professionals who want to develop their leadership, management and quality improvement skills.
Our Level 5 Diploma in Leadership and Management for Adult Care supports professional development for people working in suitable leadership and management roles.
Whether you're a Deputy Manager, aspiring Registered Manager or experienced care leader, developing your knowledge of governance, accountability and quality improvement is an important part of your professional journey.
Interested in progressing your career in Adult Care?
Visit KIB Healthcare Training to explore our qualifications
Telephone: 0121 582 4272
Official CQC Guidance and Further Reading
For further information, visit the following official Care Quality Commission resources:
- CQC Regulation 12 – Safe care and treatment
- CQC Regulation 17 – Good governance
- CQC Regulation 20 – Duty of candour
- CQC – Learning culture
- CQC – Safe systems, pathways and transitions
Disclaimer: This article provides general information for adult social care providers in England. It does not replace current CQC guidance, statutory obligations, professional clinical advice or an organisation's own safeguarding and incident management procedures.



